"Gritty and realistic" ??????????????? We must have been watching different movies. And besides, grit and realism do not a good movie make... I want interesting characters with some kind of development, a plot, good camera work and for scifi, great set design and CG.
If you'll notice what I posted, I said ID4 was not good.... Only better than this lump. Please don't think that I rate ID4 as anything other than a mindless popcorn flick. But, it was certainly more entertaining than BLA. I guess we won't agree, especially after your hard sell on the first post

Speaking of lumps, did you see The Punisher? That was Thomas Jane... who totally looks like Aaron Eckhart

Caveats apply as it is entirely possible that the information contained in the above post is either an attempt at a wind-up, an attempt at a joke or just plain wrong.